Oil Giant Prevails in Legal Battle Against Climate Activists

A major oil company has won a court case against climate activists, impacting future environmental campaigns and corporate accountability debates. 

British oil giant Shell has secured a victory in a significant case against environmental groups in the Netherlands, who had called for the energy corporation to significantly cut its greenhouse gas emissions.

According to a statement released by the corporation on Tuesday, the appeals court in The Hague has reversed a 2021 decision in the case filed against Shell by Friends of the Earth, several other NGOs, and a group of individuals.

In 2019, environmental activists filed a lawsuit against the company, claiming that Shell was responsible for reducing its greenhouse gas emissions to safeguard people from global warming.

A ruling two years later mandated that Shell reduce its carbon emissions by 45% by the year 2030, using 2019 levels as a baseline. This directive applied not only to the company’s direct emissions but also to those stemming from the use of its products—like individuals burning Shell’s fuel in their vehicles.

The court declared that the oil and gas company must adhere to the “worldwide agreement” requiring a 45% net reduction in greenhouse gas emissions by 2030, which is essential for limiting global temperature rise to 1.5°C (2.7°F) above pre-industrial levels. This target was established under the international climate change treaty known as the Paris Agreement of 2016.

On Tuesday, the appeals court in The Hague overturned the entire ruling, noting that Shell was actively working to lower its emissions. Reuters reported that the court also mentioned it was uncertain if requiring emission reductions related to Shell’s product usage would effectively contribute to combating climate change.

READ ALSO: Fuel supply will not fall short again this year — NNPCL

In its announcement, the British corporation reaffirmed its commitment to achieving net-zero emissions as an energy business by 2050 and is actively pursuing a goal of reducing operational emissions by half by 2030.

“The last few years have emphasized the vital need for secure and affordable energy in both economies and people’s lives,” it observed.

Friends of the Earth called the verdict “a setback for climate justice,” but noted that it would “only strengthen climate groups’ resolve as they persist in opposing major polluters.”

According to individuals knowledgeable about the process, as reported by the Financial Times, the environmental organization has a three-month window to file an appeal with the Dutch Supreme Court. The court would then take approximately 18 months to reach a final decision.

Shell ranks among the world’s largest investor-owned oil and gas companies in terms of revenue. The Carbon Majors database indicates that from 2016 to 2023, this British energy giant was a major contributor to greenhouse gas emissions, accounting for at least 1% of global emissions.